Toronto vs New York City head-to-head

Toronto and New York City have met 6 times on our records since 2024: Toronto won 0, New York City won 4, and 2 matches ended level. The most recent was on 29 Aug 2026: Toronto 1–1 New York City in the Major League Soccer.

Toronto have scored 6 in this fixture to New York City's 11 — 2.8 goals a match, and both sides scored in 5 of the 6. The biggest win was New York City's 3–1 in 2025.

Kevin O'Toole (New York City) has scored 2 goals in this fixture, more than anyone else. Nicolás Fernández Mercau has 2 and Santiago Rodríguez has 2.

Across those 6 meetings the referees showed 37 yellow cards and 2 reds — 6.2 yellows a match.

In their last 5 across all competitions, Toronto took 7 points and New York City 2.